Monday, November 24, 2008
Health Insurance
I thought that the second reading on health care was very effective. The author used many reliable statistics that shocked me and appealed to pathos throughout his entire paper. Also, he used a great method for pathos when he talked about a personal story that some people could relate to or show the realities of the problem to people who can't relate. The story made it sound like Ian's situation was somewhat hopeless, and to find out that it is a common story with millions of Americans made it much more effective on the audience. A good example of pathos as well was when he was talking about how going to the emergency room was extremely expensive, and that it would cost more to amputate a limb of an extremely sick diabetic vs. getting care in the first place and getting insulin and having check ups. Also, Bonicillo made sure to include some possible disputes about reforming health insurance, such as the fear of socialized insurance like in European countries. His proposal was well thought out so that it would solve all of the current problems of our health insurance policy and wouldn't become a socialized medicine. I liked how the author related back to his story about Ian, and how under the proposals he made, Ian would have insurance for his back and could go to the hospital to treat it.
Tuesday, November 18, 2008
Relationships Between Races
Yes, Ellis's story does offer a credible way to overcome bad relations between races because it is a thing in itself that he was the head guy of the KKK, and yet he gradually came to realize that blacks and other races had more in common with him than he realized, and weren't the type of people they claimed them to be in their cause. Also, his father was a part of the Klan as well, so that view and prejudice was passed on to him, and yet he grew to know the black woman, Ann, that he hated, and found out that he could become good friends with her and had much in common with her. Being part of organization with various races in it also helped him overcome his prejudice and hatred for blacks and Jews. I'm not totally sure it would work completely in a larger scale, but it would on a certain degree. Not everyone is going to be able to overcome their prejudices and hatred for certain races, and realize the things he did throughout the years to help him come to this result. However, for the people who are similar to Ellis in the way that they can gradually overcome their hatred will help in the larger scale as well, and gradually spread to others.
Monday, November 17, 2008
Yoshino explains in the later part of his article that the word "mainstream" is a myth. It's a myth because everyone is different and individual, therefore no one can truly lump certain people into the mainstream because all those people would not quite fit into it. He is persuasive when he talks about it because he uses good logic when he says "Because human beings hold many identities, the mainstream is a shifting coalition, and non of us are entirely within it. It is not normal to be completely normal." (605) That statement makes a lot of sense, and helps prove that mainstream is a myth. I especially liked how he said that it is weird and unusual to be completely normal. To help back that up, he uses the example of a white, straight, protestant man. However, even though they have those common traits, they still have other quirks in their personality and identities that make each of those men that fit those four traits slightly different. I would define mainstream as people who have certain larger traits in common.
Sunday, November 16, 2008
Freedom?
No, unfortunately life in the North was not what she hoped. Even though she felt free at times, she truly wasn't. She always had to be aware of meeting Southerners who might recognize her in the streets, especially her old master. Also, Linda expected life in the North to be totally different from the South life, which in some ways it was. However, she had always heard much about the abolitionists, and thought she wouldn't be treated horribly as she was when she was in slavery. However, even though the Northerners didn't beat her or force her to work without pay, there was still color prejudice. Despite her being in the Free States, many whites still looked down on her and verbally acted on that prejudice against her and other blacks. For example, when Linda and Fanny first arrived to New York, they were bargaining a price for a taxi, and when they finally set a price with one man, they found out that he was trying to make them pay to sit in the back of a truck. Also, when Linda was the nurse for Mrs. Bruce (the first one), she was treated unfairly in nice hotels, and was told to feed the child and for her not to get a seat and eat in the kitchen after the meal. The rest of the other maids had fair treatment except her, just because of her skin color.
Linda finally gains her freedom when Mrs. Bruce (the second one) paid for her freedom from Mr. and Mrs. Dodge, who had come in search to take Linda back and sell her themselves for money. Through a lawyer, Mrs. Bruce was able to pay little for Linda, and granted Linda her freedom once the deal was made. Linda had mixed emotions about this because she was extremely grateful and relieved towards Mrs. Bruce and happy for her true freedom, but she felt that she shouldn't need to have to pay for her freedom in the first place.
Monday, November 10, 2008
Emotional Passage
One passage that was particularly emotional was on pg. 69, when Dr. Flint through Ben across the room. I was shocked that it went as far as that, and that anyone would throw a child and knock him unconscious! Jacobs goes farther with the moment to mention how she thought he was dead, and how her master wouldn't let her go to Ben until she managed to escape from his grasp and people came into the room. By screaming, "Let go!", it shows her panic and her mother instincts kicking in, something some people can relate to. Even if you're not a mother, you can somewhat imagine what that would be like, watching your child thrown across the room and thought to be dead. Also, Jacobs describes how Ben was 'pale and still', and kept thinking he might be dead until he finally came to. However, instead of being happy that he was still alive, she finishes the paragraph and sentence by saying "...I don't know whether I was very happy." She's not saying she doesn't love Ben, but she doesn't want him to go through this life and a possible future life of slavery. This passage particularly plays on the audience's emotion by describing something that you wouldn't even ever think of, and describing the feeling she felt as it happened and what exactly happened.
Sunday, November 9, 2008
ILSG
It is important that it is truth and not fiction because then the audience can't get away with saying that 'oh, it's fiction, the author is exaggerating the events'. Since it is what actually happened and she experienced it herself, they have to acknowledge that these things happened, even if some of the events described seem to horrible to have actually happened. It is important for the audience to understand that these horrible crimes committed against the slaves actually did happen, and not just some made up stories in order to bring out sympathy for what happened. Also, a fictional story won't have as much of an impact since the audience knows that everything in the story is not true and therefore doesn't effect them as much. However, if it is a true story, they can't escape from the fact that it happened and it effects them a lot more, knowing these things actually happened to real people and the author. Also, if the editor had changed it, that would have taken away from the raw material that Jacobs wrote, and lessen the impact of the book. If she had edited the language that pops up in the book, it would have made it less real, and add a fictional element to the material because some slaves didn't speak proper english, and would have made that part fictional.
Tuesday, November 4, 2008
Elections
My parents watch Fox News, so that's the channel I ended up watching. Surprisingly, even though they were unbiased most of the time throughout the night, they seemed to lean towards Obama, which is weird because Fox News tends to be known for being more Republican, which is why my parents watch it. They were unbiased in the way that they brought in different speakers for both candidates and showed clips of supporters. However, they were biased in the way that, with the touch screen things with the map of which way each state went as far as they knew, they focused on mostly the states Obama won (which in a way is understandable since they were important ones for him) and kept repeating on how certain types of voters went mostly for Obama, and kept coming back to the thought that people in certain states though McCain would be like Bush.
Something that surprised me was that I have been hearing so much about how Indiana was a battleground state for once, but when it came to some of the polling, McCain was winning, and we didn't even matter in the end because Obama was elected president after California's polls came in. Also, at the moment they are talking about how the younger generation is colorblind, while the older generation isn't as much, which I also thought was interesting.
Monday, November 3, 2008
Encounters
I haven't had many racial encounters at all, considering I have been attending small, private schools all my life that teaches diversity. However, there was one outside of my past schools, when I was in this one choir in middle school. Most of the time, this choir teaches similar values as University, but of course they don't go into as much depth as our school does, and the choir is filled with kids from many different schools. One day, before choir started, I happened to be there early and was talking with a person I didn't know that well at that point. At one point, this person randomly brought up one of the black singers in our choir, and how this person thought that it was unfair that she always got solos in songs and called her the n word. I was shocked, and just stared at the person, while they in turn had no idea what they did wrong. Before anything else happened, choir started and I had to go to my seat for warmups. It was not productive at all, and it was upsetting to me that a person would use that word against the girl, not to mention that the person who said it was white. After reading the article, I don't really understand the situation in a different way.
Sunday, November 2, 2008
Socialization Process
According to Parrillo, the socialization process is where "individuals acquire the values, beliefs, and perceptions of their culture or subculture, including religion, nationality, and social class." (514) By using the most common example, he explained how, as a child, you learn a certain view of the world from your parents when you are most impressionable. Therefore, prejudices can be based down from parent to child, and become part of their beliefs and influence our attitude towards that group, even if it is wrong. I do think that with some prejudices, this process in getting them is true. Obviously not all prejudices are formed this way, as explained in the article, but I do see how this process is true. I have actually had a similar conversation with a friend about this, only we didn't know it was called this, and how we and others we know have mentioned that, once they thought about it, some prejudices they have they have learned from their parents. One friend mentioned how their parents' view on politics have strongly influenced her as she grew up, and discovered that she now shares a similar view as her parents because of that early influence. Another example I commonly see with this process is abortion and gay, bi, and transexual people. Whether due to religion or any other beliefs, their (the parents') view is often influenced to their children so that they tend to believe the same view on these things.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)