Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Against School

I could agree with some of what Gatto was saying, but on the other hand shocked, or surprised would be a better word, at other conclusions he came to about the school system. I agree how on pg. 157, he mentions in #5  that the schools tag kids who have bad grades, etc. and their classmates look down on them somewhat, with the whole Darwin idea. Even if the schools are wrong about that student that they labeled, and they are actually very smart and capable, it is what they do based on how well they do within the system. They constantly rank kids with test scores and GPA, and it separates and labels everyone. I also agree that schools do tend to conform. Even though I never went to a public school, my friends tell me a great deal about how it is so much different from private schools, esp. UHS, and how it is more conformist instead of individuality and original thought. I could also see how children can be shaped while they are younger, and later have the urge to constantly consume more and more, and never be alone (always having computer, cell phone, etc.). However, I'm not sure his conclusion that the school system is trying to turn us all "into servants" (159) or determine what social role a person will achieve in society. 

1 comment:

Bailey Nuckols said...

Cate,
I agree with what you are saying in every concept. But I also think it is hard to tell when we both have only been emerged in the "exceptions" Gatto is referring to. We both haven't been pushed to the side or allowed to slip through the cracks. Our success has been important to every single one of our teachers, so reading this essay from the perspective that we both have gained makes it difficult to see all his negativities in the schooling system he points out.