Tuesday, September 16, 2008

Evidence in Skateboarding Piece

I think that, overall, David Langley uses evidence well in his essay of the unfair treatment of skateboarders. He uses various types such as personal experience, testimony, and a couple of other kinds of evidence. He narrowly focuses on the treatment of skaters when rules and signs are unclear, which is a typical situation that happens in life. However, he doesn't focus on the skaters that contribute to the way they are being treated by skating recklessly and not following the rules. Also, even though starting his essay with a personal experience was a great way to start to get the audience on his side, he jumps to a conclusion soon after the story that he doesn't support with facts or quotes. He states that people view them as misfits, which might be true in some cases, but he doesn't prove that people view them that way. He only assumes that based off how store owners and the police treat them. Another observation I made was that although he used great testimonies and personal experiences to get to the audience, he doesn't use any facts or surveys to help his argument. However, the multitude of evidence he did use was effective in most ways to help prove his argument.
Langley's evidence was used much more effective than the author of A Case For Torture was. In the torture essay, the author mostly used hypothetical situations that would rarely happen, and no actual situations or statistics. Although he did conduct a survey, it is definitely not accurate because he said he only asked four mothers, and four people cannot represent an entire group. 

1 comment:

Ian Ketcham said...

I agree with your overall premise. Langely assumes that skaters are considered misfits, but he does not specifically say where he draws that conclusion from. His encounter with the police would seem to suggest this line of reasoning, but I feel this is insufficient. The police officer was simply enforcing the laws he was charged to enforce. The reaction of the police officer is hardly grounds to suggest that all or the majority of people who live in cities see skaters as misfits. I concur with your thesis statement that the evidence in this piece is utilized well. I feel the real issue is whether or not there is enough of it (in my opinion the answer is no). I suppose that your assertion that Langely uses evidence better than Levine is correct (neither really rely an overabundance of actual evidence, both provide situations in which you were be foolish to disagree with author). While Levine's survey was biased and inaccurate, he still managed to support himself with more non-subjective evidence than Langely did, and in this regard, I feel that 'A Case for Torture' is the stronger piece of writing.