Monday, September 15, 2008

Real Life Pseudo-Arguments

Although I have heard multiple pseudo-arguments from both fanatical believers and fanatical skeptics, the most shocking pseudo-argument I have ever heard was that the holocaust never happened. I'm not sure if this a true pseudo-argument because they are arguing against a true fact, but they still try to argue their view in the present. This argument also fails to fulfill the two extra factors that a rational argument needs, which are people who are willing to use reasonable behavior and they need to share certain assumptions to use as a starting point. I couldn't believe that some people were even arguing that, but it's an actual view they try to argue, but never get very far with their side of the argument. Even when we prove to them that the holocaust did actually happen, they are fanatical believers and refuse to let our overwhelming evidence change their view. Of course, the people arguing against them refuse to change their view on the topic because it is a fact that the holocaust happened, so the argument becomes stuck and won't grow or change anything. 

No comments: