However, when I first read the essay, I read with an open mind without the perspective of a believer or a doubter, and my reaction afterwards was that even though he seemed very convincing and had some good points, I didn't totally agree with him, and was even bothered by some of the things he wrote. Not only was I bothered by the 'obviously guilty' statement, there was another sentence that went along with that example which could lead to horrible outcomes. The author said that terrorist groups would be public about what they are doing, but not all are open about their actions. Some can be more quiet about it and attack and demand things when it is too late for the government to react or know exactly who they are. Another paragraphed that bothered me was when he used the 'kidnapped baby' situation, and mentions how he asked mothers. Of course mothers would agree to torture in order to get their baby back, it is their child and related to them! Also, as mentioned in class, it says that the author only asked four mothers, which can't represent a whole group. Despite the larger points he made for his argument, we can't be sure if they are truly true because he doesn't go into much depth. But if you stop and think about some of the points he is making, you sometimes realize that their is more behind it that could be set against that point.
Monday, September 8, 2008
Response to Essay on Torture
If I read as a believer, I would admit that the author's writing style is very convincing because it goes from one narrowly focused point to the next. Also, those specific points that he make to prove his argument do a good job of validating his position. However, if you look at the other end of the spectrum, his writing style breezes over the not as strong points that could be used against him, and he does well not to mention things that could lead to a point against him. Also, because the points he uses are so narrowly focused, and with specific hypothetical situations, some can be a rare occurrence. For example, he mentions how if we know who they bad guy is and is obviously guilty and we torture him, than there is that line still there between Us and Them. However, how often do we know the exact bad guy? In some cases, yes, we know and have captured them, but that doesn't always happen, and what if someone you thought was 'obviously guilty' and turned out not to be?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment