Tuesday, September 2, 2008
How Genres Influence Arguements
As explained in the Writing Arguments textbook, an argument's genre can have a great influence on the argument and point of view you are presenting to your argument, with some genres better than others with certain views. All the genres are capable of communicating their views, but some are more likely to be used than others on some topics based on your audience and background, and other such factors. Using the genetic manipulation within food example, the book had provided two opposing sides of the issue using the same genre of visual arguments. Although both approaches used visuals to help them communicate their points, the ad on page 24 is actually within the genre of advocacy ads, and the cartoon on page 1 is a visual argument. If I was looking at these two genres and views of the same issue without knowing much background information, I would be instantly swayed to believe in the ad to keep food natural. The ad shows a shocking twist to a normal part of foods that we see, along with using convincing facts within the writing below the picture. The information they provided would get me thinking about what I'm buying and eating, and make me worried about what is happening when they genetically engineer the food that I eat and what the possible effects it could have on me. However, when I look at the cartoon on page 1, it impacts me in a different way, and sends me along a different train of thought than they probably intended. Instead of thinking about their view of the issue or how they might be attempting to respond to the ad, I end up thinking instead that, most likely, a starving person like the one pictured in the cartoon would not likely care if it was modified or not, just as long as they are able to have food. I get what they are trying to get at, but if a person didn't know much about the topic then I don't think they would quite get at what the artist was intending, although it also depends on where this cartoon was shown and the audience.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
I agree with you that the ad impacted me greater than the cartoon. Because they supplied information we were able to understand the add better. The cartoon was an argument but I agree with you that if you did not know background information about the topic it would be difficult to understand the argument that they were trying to convey.
Post a Comment