Tuesday, September 30, 2008
Stephen Cruz vs. Horatio Alger
At the beginning, Cruz had a similar idea to Alger's, about how to achieve in America and live the American Dream. He believed that the multitude of job offers was due to his talents and determination. He didn't realize until later that there was a great amount of discrimination that occurred in the world of jobs, and that the American Dream is much more complex than it is made out to be. Alger tends to not put in the complex factors such as race, gender, and all those other characteristics that complicate and even start to disprove the American Dream. Dalton talks about that in his piece about Alger, saying that the majority of his stories just show people go from "rags to riches" with hard work and essentially luck. Cruz, through the writing of Terkel, disproves that simple equation with his own experiences and observations. Even though it seemed like he was living the American Dream to others, he couldn't help but notice facts that ultimately changed and destroyed what he thought was the American Dream. Minorities had less opportunities, and you have to "fall in line" to be successful. Terkel, writing as Cruz, says, "The American Dream, I see now, is governed not by education, opportunity, and hard work, but by power and fear. The higher up in the organization you go, the more you have to lose. The dream is not losing. This is the notion pervading America today: don't lose." (356) This quote immediately disproves Alger's version of individual opportunity and the American Dream. Although, if you don't include all of what Cruz argues, then in a way Cruz's experience somewhat follows Alger's theme because he went from a bad neighborhood to earning 50 grand a year, and had luck with timing and job opportunities.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Good job synthesizing everything. You did a good job explaining what happened. Its interesting that you think of Cruz and Dick as having similar stories, though. You say that Dick "made it" for the same basic reasons that Cruz did. But what if Dick had been Chinese? Do you think they would have had similar stories then? It's probably more likely that Dick got his nice job because he was at the right place, right time, and right ethnicity. Cruz didn't have the same experience because he wasn't at the right place, at the right time. If someone with no where near as much credentials was in his place, he probably would have gotten to (more or less) the same place as Cruz did. But overall, nice post.
Post a Comment